ELU/Science_Jan 19, 2004
Some Notes & Reflections on 162 Students' Final Project
by Buthaina Al Othman
The purpose of this report is to describe my reflection on an experiment, using a synchronous computer mediated communication, (CMC), tool,a Virtual Room at Alado.net/Webheads, where 9 of my students, registered in an ESP, English for Science course # 162 volunteered to present their required final project live online. The rest of the class, 13 students preferred to present in-class.
The 9 students presented, before remote global audience comprising ESL/EFL Webhead teachers from Denmark, Spain, Australia, Saudi Arabia, Portugal, Germany, and Brazil. The local audience, comprised a few EFL instructors from the English Language unit of Science in Kuwait University, and the 13 students.
Notes & Comments:
would like to confirm, as the class teacher, that the positive outcome
of the online presentations was remarkable, and significantly reflected
on both groups, the 9 online and the 13 in-class presenters, later throughout
the end of the in-class presentations week.
of both groups was beyond my expectation in that the 9-student group,
being the audience, took the role of the Webhead teachers in the following
1. They were
very observant and focused on each presentation, asking intelligent and
interesting questions in a very efficient and professional manner.
2. They attended
all presentations on time, showing respect, interest and enthusiasm toward
the 13-student group; since they realized the important role of the audience
to a presenter, following their online presentations
3. Most of
them, including the poorest student performed much better in the final
exam, particularly in the essay writing that was to be produced by combining
notes and phrases from a 5-paragraph essay detailed outline format.
4. Some of the nine students have registered in an advanced elective writing course # 163, stressing their need to enhance their academic writing skill. Meanwhile, other students asked for tips and recommendations on how to practice their English speaking, listening and writing skills via the Internet. (I directed them to Writing for Webheads, but haven't seen any of them joined the community, yet).
These were the positive desirable results regarding the online presenters.
As for the 13 in-class presenters, the following remarks were noticed:
1. Most of
the students who created PowerPoint slides to use for their presentations
modified the slides after they saw the lay out and organization of the
online PowerPoint presentations. Some of them were very creative and managed
to add images and sound.
their actual performance, presenting in-class, they were very skillful
as first time, face-to-face presenters. They spoke in a loud, clear voice
and used good English that was beyond my expectation.
3. Most of
them managed to maintain good eye contact with the audience, while reading
directly from their slides projected on a screen.
4. They responded
to the audience's questions efficiently, practicing what they saw and
heard at the distance-learning center, where they observed the online
presenters closely and learned what to say when they don't have a ready
answer to an inquiry. They used professional expressions, such as, "I'm
sorry I don't know the answer or I'm sorry I didn't search this point
but I promise to further search it and bring you the answer as soon as
I can". (I was very impressed as this was also beyond my expectations,
regarding responses in this kind of situations).
final exam results, in fact, showed higher achievement than those presented
online, which their midterm results, on the contrary, showed higher achievement.
6. Some of them also asked for tips and recommendations on ways to improve their English, writing and speaking skills in particular, during this Spring break, officially, starting this Wednesday. (They were also told to join Writing for Webheads).
In conclusion, I believe that the webcast project or the online activities, using a synchronous computer mediated communication, (CMC) tool, such as, the webcasting tool of Alado.net/Webheads, is feasible, and has resulted in a positive, desirable outcome for both students and the class instructor. It has positively influenced and motivated both groups, benefiting them with various language, computer and Internet or IT skills. The main outcome that I would like to stress here is that this webcast activity has created a constructive academic competition between the two groups, enhancing their face-to-face and e-learning experiences. By asking for tips and recommendations on ways to improve their English language, students are actually taking their first step toward independent learning, which I believe is the first step towards the future or the 21st Century.
Back to Evaluation page
©2003-04 Buthaina Al Othman